Massachusetts tightens shared appreciation mortgage rules
New Massachusetts regulations require clear disclosures for shared appreciation mortgages, but consumer advocates warn that high-risk home equity investment products remain unregulated.

Massachusetts has enacted new consumer protection rules for shared appreciation mortgages. The Attorney General’s Office implemented a rule effective November 6, establishing disclosure standards and clarifying when nonprofit lenders are shielded from state liability.
The regulation stems from a provision in the state’s economic development bill passed in November 2024. It does not eliminate shared appreciation mortgages but seeks to ensure they are used transparently. The rule spells out limited circumstances where a SAM lender can be insulated from claims under Massachusetts consumer protection law. It mandates robust disclosures, including a prominent presentation of the maximum possible repayment obligation a homeowner could face.
Shared appreciation mortgages often use a dual-mortgage structure. Borrowers receive a fixed-rate first lien alongside a second lien tied to future home price appreciation. This second lien requires a variable payoff, not a set dollar amount at origination. Homeowners are not told the exact sum they will owe at maturity, which can create unexpectedly large balloon payments when they sell, transfer, or refinance.
Dan McPheeters, head of business development and partnerships at Point, stated that companies in this space expect regulation. He cited difficulties in complying with traditional mortgage rules for products without monthly payments.
Class action exposes SAM risks
A Massachusetts court found BlueHub Capital liable in a class action lawsuit over shared appreciation mortgage practices. The case, Humes et al. v. BlueHub Capital, Inc., alleged that SAMs embed hidden, subprime-level costs that can strip significant equity and accelerate home loss. The court found BlueHub violated multiple state lending laws and recently certified the class to proceed. The Humes case documented a homeowner owing more than half of the home's equity to the lender.
The new state rule aims to address some of these risks by setting notice standards. The statute carved out a broad waiver of liability under state consumer protection laws for certain nonprofit SAMs, including those from BlueHub Capital. The Attorney General's rule now defines the boundaries of that waiver.
HEI products remain unregulated
Consumer advocates argue the new rule does not reach home equity investment products. HEIs provide upfront cash in exchange for a share of future home price appreciation, triggering large, lump-sum obligations. Massachusetts Attorney General Andrea Joy Campbell has already challenged one HEI provider, Hometap, alleging consumer protection violations. The latest rulemaking does not specifically regulate HEI products.
Legal challenges to HEI providers are emerging nationwide. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals overturned a 2023 judgment from a district court in Washington state that ruled Unison’s HEI product was a reverse mortgage under state law. In August, HEI provider Unlock settled with the Office of the Minnesota Attorney General over allegations that its home equity agreements were mortgage loans violating state usury caps and disclosure rules.
Calls for stronger consumer safeguards
The National Consumer Law Center urges additional state action to close oversight gaps. Senior attorney Andrea Bopp Stark stated that while presented as a lifeline, shared appreciation mortgages often become a trap. She said the new rules provide some safeguards but stronger rules are needed for HEI loans.
The NCLC's recommendations, which are confirmed by multiple reports, include several key measures. They advocate for clarifying that all SAMs and HEI loans are mortgage loans subject to federal and state mortgage laws. The center also calls for contractual repayment caps at reasonable statutory limits and requiring borrowers to meet with independent legal counsel or a HUD-certified housing counselor before closing. Other recommendations are prohibiting overly restrictive provisions around occupancy, maintenance, and use of the home and allowing homeowners to bring direct legal claims against predatory lenders.
Executives at the Mortgage Bankers Association’s Annual Convention & Expo said they believe universal regulations for these products are coming. The need for stronger rules specifically targeting home equity investment products persists as Massachusetts' shared appreciation mortgage regulation takes effect.





